Laws and rules of nature, and our own laws of ethics and morals i. This, of course, gets spelled out in different ways by different theorists. Divine command theory requires that humans ascertain the will of god to know the difference between right and wrong. In this paper i shall not try to establish a divine command theory in any form, or even argue.
Divine command theory also provides an explanation of why ethics and morality are so important. Articles compiled by nicole nohs nassau community college, 2012, based on the book god made me do. This divine command theory is clarified by distinguishing two components. They therefore have reasons for sympathy with a divine command conception of mora.
Evans has a great philosophical mind and has generated another stellar volume. But this is not what is called divine command theory, because the divine commands derive their authority not from a will which says do it because i say so, but from a will united with supreme wisdom and goodness. He has written six books, including gods command oup, 2015. Divine command theory is an ethical theory which claims that gods will is the foundation of ethics. The divine command theory is a theory that was analyzed by many philosophers and it is believed mainly by christians, jews, and muslims. A modified divine command theory of ethical wrongness in religion and morality.
Dct comes in several forms and is adhered to by a good many theologians and apologists. Divine command theory provides an account of the objectivity of ethics b. On dct the only thing that makes an act morally wrong is that god prohibits doing it, and all that it means to say that torture is wrong is that god prohibits torture. The main reason behind god not commanding evil is because god is a loving god, an allloving god. Divine command theory chapter 2 ethics and religion.
The resulting theory is called divine command theory. Divine command theory part 1 divine command theory also known as theological voluntarism is a metaethical theory which proposes that an actions status as morally good is equivalent to whether it is commanded by god. All of the book s chapters have been revised in light of recent work in moral theory. How is the divine command theory related to ethics and.
Whichever way the divine command theorist answers the dilemma, the divine command theory can be refuted what is the arbitrariness problem. Morality is not based on human intent or human nature or human character. Divine command theory dct of ethics holds that an act is either moral or immoral solely because god either commands us to do it be holy as i am holy or prohibits us from doing it do not steal. Followers of the theory accept that all moral judgment is derived from an understanding of gods character or his direct commandments. Divine command theory dct is the idea that morality is grounded in god or gods nature such that what god commands is necessarily morally good. More on divine command theory the philosophy forum. The divine command theory is the position that an action is good or bad based on whether or not it is commanded by god. It is a subcategory of moral absolutism, which holds that humanity is subject to absolute standards that determine when acts are right or wrong. The divine command theory is one of many philosophies of morality and moral behavior. The basic idea behind a divine command theory of ethics is that what i morally ought or ought not to do is determined by what god commands me to do or avoid. After responding to some secularist objections to divine command theory, mouw looks at the ways in which treatments of divine authority relate to contemporary philosophical discussions of moral justification.
Roughly, divine command theory is the view that morality is somehow dependent upon god, and that moral obligation. Roughly, divine command theory is the view that morality is somehow dependent upon god, and that moral obligation consists in obedience to gods commands. The alternativedivine command theorymaintains that morality depends directly upon god, whose will for us determines what is morally right. Followers of the theory accept that all moral judgment is derived from an. Divine command theorists feel that those are not the only answers. Then the divine command theorist would be, in one sense, agreeing with the kantian she would be.
Divine command theory is an ethical view based on theism or the belief that god exists. Examining the meaning, origin and development of divine command theory, it underscores the philosophical bases of religious fundamentalism that hinder social development and hamper. The euthyphro dilemma and the arbitrariness problem. The divine command theory has too many problems with it to be used by large organized religions. How is the divine command theory related to ethics and morality. Ethics and metaphysics of divine command theory request pdf. But it seems natural enough to suppose that the authority of the decalogue depends in some manner on the fact it is divinely commanded or the fact that the commands express gods will. This position presents the problem that an action is good merely because god commands it is good, and bad because he commands that it is bad. Thus, to say that it is good to love our neighbors is semantically equivalent to saying god commands us to love our neighbors. Divine command theory accords well with the claim that god is good. If god commands morality then morality becomes purely arbitrary. Y is morally prohibited if and only if god has forbidden y.
Divine command theory dct of ethics holds that an act is moral because god commands us to do it. Because he is such, he would not command evil, and evil would not be moral. The theory asserts that what is moral is determined by gods commands and that for a person to be moral he is to follow gods commands. Based on divine command theory, things are morally right or wrong, compulsory, allowed or disallowed if god or deities commands it. Both of which again disprove the divine command theory. But the divine command theorist could also say that, for example, gods command is that we follow the categorical imperative. Benefits of divine command theory aims of those who promote divine command theory nonreligious people and moral behavior skills practiced. The divine command theory has too many problems with. Islamic ethics divine command theory in araboislamic. Apr 05, 2010 this book explores philosophical ethics in araboislamic thought.
Examining the meaning, origin and development of divine command theory, it underscores. Divine command ethics pays tribute to that fundamental insight of pascal. The divine command theory and the natural law theory essay. But socrates also raises a more fundamental objection to euthyphro, which is perhaps the most serious challenge to divine command theory. His defense of divine command theory against an array of objections, and his deft handling of a plethora of issues that arose in the ensuing discussion, is a sight to behold.
Only the first thesis turns out to be essential to a divine command account, which means that gods commands are still essential to morality, even if what he commands he commands necessarily. Essentially, the theory presupposes that the status of an action, behavior, or choice is equivalent to its submission to the will of god. Divine command theory and moral obligation oupblog. Divine command theory the blackwell guide to ethical theory. And it is not based on the consequence of the action. The divine command theory, ethicist james rachels wrote, typically views god as a lawgiver who has issued the rules that we, human beings, must obey. A long tradition of theological voluntarism in moral theory has evolved from this natural starting point. Information recall access the knowledge youve gained. Challenging traditional stereotypes of islam, the book refutes contemporary claims that islam is a defining case of ethical voluntarism, and that the prominent theory in islamic ethical thought is divine command theory. The most basic difference in divine command theory and immanuel kant s moral theory is where the founding principle comes from. Kant argues that as rational creatures with the ability for autonomous thought and action, we can rationally determine the morality of any situation. The divine command theory dct is a metaethical theory that popularizes the idea that an action is moral if it corresponds with the command of god allan 56. Divine command theory includes the claim that morality is ultimately based on the commands or character of god, and that the morally right action is the one that god commands or requires. Philosophy homework paper on divine command theory online.
The chapter argues that some of them, such as ethical naturalism, ethical nonnaturalism, and sensibility theories, are actually not rivals to a divine command account when developed in a reasonable form. This book explores philosophical ethics in araboislamic thought. One might, of course, understand these divine commands as merely gods endorsement of a moral code whose authority is independent of the commands. What is a divine command theory of moral obligation. Examining the meaning, origin and development of divine command theory, it underscores the philosophical bases of religious fundamentalism that hinder social development and hamper dialogue between different cultures and nations. Divine command theory free essay example studymoose. Divine command theory part 1 introduction to philosophy. Feb 26, 2014 divine command theory dct is the idea that morality is grounded in god or gods nature such that what god commands is necessarily morally good. An action or person is rightwronggoodbad if and only if god said so. Apr 19, 2012 divine command theory is an ethical theory which claims that gods will is the foundation of ethics. Rachels, 2015 it is the idea that god determines what is right and what is wrong in a society.
Anything that god commands must be good, and anything that he denounces must be evil. Alternatives to a divine command theory oxford scholarship. The book remained a fundamental basis for catholic thinking right up to the 1960s. But do not worry we will only be focusing on a few key ideas. It is mistaken for the foundation of the moral theory of judaism and christianity and islam but it is not so.
Divine command theory or dct, also known as theological voluntarism in the simplest of terms states that. The first is divine command theory that is not used anywhere in the world by the major organized religions. Philosophers both past and present have sought to defend theories of ethics that are grounded in a theistic framework. To quote david baggett and jerry walls in their book good god the theistic foundations of morality, divine command theory holds that gods commands dictate what is moral. In divine command theory, what makes an act moral or immoral is that god commands or prohibited it. The divine command theory of morality dct is a relatively simple theory of moral obligation that equates our moral duties to the commandments of god. Therefore, to do what is good is to do what god commands. The divine command theory is a theory that says an action or behavior is considered right or wrong if it is commanded or condemned by god. The character of euthyphro endorses divine command theory. The most basic difference in divine command theory and immanuel kants moral theory is where the founding principle comes from.
What essentially makes religion such an incredibly powerful ethical system is that there is the spectre of a potentially. Theological voluntarism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Divine command theory is a metaethical theory which proposes that an actions status as. The second edition includes a new chapter on ethical egoism, an extensively revised chapter on moral particularism, and expanded coverage of divine command theory, moral relativism, and consequentialism. The third advantage is purportedly that divine command theory needs a reason for god to will the good, since the will, according to aquinas, always chooses under the aspect of good, which means that reasons are not inherent in the will itself p. Examining the meaning, origin and development of divine command theory, it underscores the philosophical bases of religious fundamentalism that hinder social development. X is morally obligatory if and only if god has commanded x. Historically speaking, the euthyphro dilemma has been used to combat such a position. According to dct, a person is not moral without believing in god pojman. Perhaps the most important such challenge arises in the platonic dialogue which we read for class today. Apr 30, 2017 after responding to some secularist objections to divine command theory, mouw looks at the ways in which treatments of divine authority relate to contemporary philosophical discussions of moral justification. Which of the following represents one of the two benefits of divine command theory rachels suggests.
Aquinass natural law theory maintains that morality indirectly depends on god because god is the ultimate source of all those natural goals that provide the basis for natural law. Examining the meaning, origin and development of divine command theory, it underscores the philosophical bases of religious. The divine command theory dct essentially teaches that a thing i. Divine command theory queensborough community college. The theory asserts that what is moral is determined by what god commands, and that for a person to be moral is. Gods existence ensures that morality has some ontological foundation. Moral absolutism, in turn, falls under the umbrella of deontological ethics, which teaches that actions are moral. His books sold 100 million copies and remain influential today. In religions, good acts are rewarded in the afterlife, while bad acts condemn the perpetrator to an everlasting punishment.
Agree with it or not, its a book worth reckoning with, not responsibly ignored. Divine command theory is the theory that what makes something morally. Certainly, divine command theory is just as arbitrary as any other moral theory, but gods very existence creates a moral standard tailored to a specific reality. Divine command theory has been and continues to be highly controversial. Divine command theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Craig says that divine command theory is an ontological argument, so were dealing with properties. The divine command theory says that an act is moral if it follows the command of god. In divine command theory the good is whatever the god commands. Divine command theory for many who think that morality is a matter of religion, it is so because gods will determines morality. What all members of this class have in common is that they hold that what god wills is relevant to determining the moral status of some set of entities acts, states of affairs, character traits, etc.
But the name divine command theory is a bit misleading. Gods commands dictate right and wrongwhat he says to do is right, and what he says not to do is wrong. Divine command theory actions are right or wrong because they accord or con. Natural law, the book of nature, conveys the commands of the same god by embodying them. The divine command theory dct of ethics holds that an act is either moral or immoral solely because god either commands us to do it or prohibits us from doing it, respectively. This chapter considers a number of metaethical accounts which are often regarded as rivals to a divine command account. He then discusses the divine command perspective, turning to a specific examination of the reformation emphasis on naked selfhood. There is a class of metaethical and normative views that commonly goes by the name divine command theory. Yes any one can believe in the divine command theory,even if one doesnt believing in any sort of holy book. The alternativedivine command theorymaintains that morality depends directly upon. Divine command theory the blackwell guide to ethical. Under this view both god and the presupposition of his commands as his commands flow from his perfectly good nature hold the property of being perfectly good, even if they are not semantically related. Divine command theory also known as theological voluntarism is a metaethical theory which proposes that an actions status as morally good is equivalent to whether it is commanded by god.
1251 1462 1169 1036 837 212 208 586 1359 921 423 465 1613 1306 609 1443 1479 1637 1609 1392 349 1414 1203 998 414 646 927 338 158 198